A warmly lit Italian restaurant window table with pizza, overlooking a quiet historic neighborhood street at November dusk.

The Uptown's Pizza Premiere Starts on Federal Hill Three Hours Before the Screenings

On Friday, November 20, the Uptown Theater at 270 Broadway hosts the international premiere of The Pizza Principal. Doors open at 7, and at 8 p.m. the program begins with three short films before the feature. The organizers set the actual start at 5 p.m., when ticket holders can begin collecting food and drink specials at participating bars and restaurants on Federal Hill.

That makes the screening the middle of the evening. Pizza comes before it and after it, and the night begins on the Hill's sidewalks. This is also the job the building was doing the last time it carried the Uptown name.

A building that went back to its old name

The theater was built in 1926 as the Columbus Theatre. WPRI, citing the Providence Preservation Society, reported that it was called the Uptown Theatre from 1929 to 1962 and that for years it staged Italian plays and films. Later it became a venue for music, comedy and community events.

Its most recent run as the Columbus Theatre lasted 12 years and ended in the summer of 2024. That October, according to WPRI, Cory Brailsford and David Fiorillo bought the building. The two own Comedy Connection and Black Duck Tavern in East Providence. They spent about a year on renovations: new lobby bars, updated electrical, plumbing and air conditioning, a rebuilt sound booth, new ceiling and bathrooms, and a refreshed small performance space upstairs. The theater reopened on August 14, 2025, under the Uptown name, with its red plush seats intact.

The venue describes its current lineup as live music, comedy, films, speakers, touring artists and community events. The film's organizers call the 2025 restoration Art Deco and point out a detail in the balcony: the seats up there are the 1926 originals.

The November 20 booking fits the building's history closely. It is a film about Rhode Islanders, made by Rhode Islanders, scheduled so the audience spends its first hours at the bars and restaurants around the theater.

Who is on the screen

The Pizza Principal comes from RI Docs, a documentary series that records the voices and stories of Rhode Islanders, including educators, artists, small business owners, activists and community leaders. Its subject is Tim Chace, a Coventry High School vice principal who set out to review 40 Rhode Island pizzerias in 30 days and become a professional writer.

In a piece for The Westerly Sun, Chace wrote that during a challenge called "Lord of the Pies" he posted a Facebook review of every pizzeria he liked, and that he and his friend Lauren started the "RI: The Pizza State" group on Facebook. The Valley Breeze reported that the group now meets in person to eat and talk pizza, and that Kirk Benttinen found Chace through his reviews on Facebook.

In a pre-premiere post on the film's Substack, Chace explains how the film came about. Kendra Benttinen read his reviews out loud to her husband, "Dramatically. With feeling." Her husband, director Kirk Benttinen, "heard a storyteller." Chace writes that Benttinen then shot nearly the whole film by himself over two years, pulling his own focus on vintage lenses.

The people on screen are the ones behind the counters. In the same post, Chace names Carmine at Merlino's and Alli at Lucky's in Foster, who quoted a last-place review back to him word for word and asked him to try again. He also names Lauren and Frank, "trading insults over every pie." These are neighborhood pizzerias from around the state:

  • Merlino's Pizzeria is at 889 Dyer Avenue in Cranston.
  • Lucky's Bar & Pizza is at 143 Danielson Pike in Foster, where the last day of shooting took place.
  • Twin's Pizza is at 1000 Mineral Spring Avenue in North Providence, where The Local Insider News reported a film crew shooting in September.

All three are outside Providence. For one night, the film brings Cranston, Foster and North Providence to Broadway.

The evening, hour by hour

The organizers built the schedule around the neighborhood:

5 p.m. Start on Federal Hill. Show your ticket at participating bars and restaurants for food and drink specials. The organizers post the list of participants on the @rhodeislanddocs Instagram account.

7 p.m. Doors open. The lobby program includes live music, roving performers, Rhode Island pizza trivia, a pizza song for the audience to sing, a community art project and pizza strips.

8 p.m. Three RI Docs short films come first. They profile Carmel Vittulo, a 100-year-old photographer; Nick McKnight, a neon bender; and Noelle Longhaul, a tattoo artist. Next is The Pizza Principal, which runs 75 minutes, followed by a Q&A with Kirk Benttinen and people from the film.

10 p.m. to 11:59 p.m. The after-party has its own ticket. The Eventbrite listing places it at the Uptown and says pizzerias from the film will be there serving.

The two hours before doors open are part of the plan. The specials window covers the stretch of a Friday evening when people tend to decide where to have dinner, and it sends them to the Hill to eat first. Chace's own subtitle for the night is "Eat first. Watch. Eat again."

Every ticket comes with a 3D-printed collectible token, which also enters the holder in a raffle for their own custom documentary.

What the building asks of you

A 1926 theater has its own rules, and some are easy to miss when you're arriving straight from dinner on Atwells. Per the organizers' guide:

  • Security. There are metal detectors at the door. Allow 30 to 45 minutes to get in.
  • Bags. Leave backpacks at home. Bags are searched and have to fit under your seat.
  • Bars. Both are cashless.
  • Tickets. They arrive by email. Scan them from your phone or Apple Wallet.
  • Seating. The first floor is wheelchair accessible. The balcony is not, and there is no elevator. The original 1926 balcony seats have no cupholders.
  • Parking. Use street parking on Broadway or the lots at 280 Broadway, 57 Sutton Street, 90 DePasquale Avenue, 107 Federal Street and 249 Atwells Avenue. SpotHero takes reservations.

Tickets cost $39.99 to $60.99, fees included, and are sold through the Uptown. If you can't make it, the film won't be streaming. Digital rentals are planned for later.

The parking list traces the neighborhood. It includes a lot next door on Broadway, lots up toward DePasquale and Atwells, and one on Federal Street. These are the same blocks the 5 p.m. specials are meant to fill, so a reasonable plan is to park once and walk the rest of the evening.

The next two Saturdays on Atwells

Federal Hill fills its own calendar the following weekends. Christmas on the Hill is listed for Saturday, November 28, from 2 to 6 p.m. on Atwells Avenue, with free trolley rides, performances and a tree lighting at 5 p.m. A second date is listed for Saturday, December 5, also 2 to 6 p.m., with music, dance, carolers and a lighting display.

Taken together, the three dates sketch the Hill's late-autumn calendar. A ticketed film night at the Broadway end starts in the restaurants. The two Saturday afternoons that follow take place on Atwells itself. The Uptown has been back for just over a year, and the November 20 premiere shows how it connects to the blocks around it.

I spend a lot of my time thinking about how old buildings find new uses, and the Uptown is a good Providence example. If you own an older home within walking distance of Broadway and want to know how its history and its location near nights like this one translate into value today, I'm glad to walk through it with you. Start with Sabine Green and the question I hear most often: What's Your Home Worth?

Expert Guidance

Helping clients navigate the real estate journey with skill, integrity, and a focus on finding the perfect home or buyer.

Follow Me on Instagram