White clapboard house with dark shutters and a columned entrance behind an autumn lawn and bluestone walk.

Thayer Street's New Businesses in Providence: Coffee & Delis

"They obviously have a strong standing financially." Harrison Dulgarian of Dulgarian Properties gave that reason when he told The Brown Daily Herald why Blank Street won the lease at 218 Thayer St., the space the Starbucks left suddenly in 2025. He said "a few dozen places" had shown interest.

That one sentence explains most of what is happening on Thayer Street this fall. The businesses that left in 2026 sold books, imported goods, boba and bagels. Every announced replacement I can name pours coffee or slices deli meat. The landlords filling the gaps want tenants who can carry the rent and pay for a full build-out. On a street that has lost a lot of tenants since spring, that has meant chains with deep pockets and East Side operators with a track record.

The ledger since May

Here is how the block looks as of early November 2026, address by address.

Location What was there What's next
218 Thayer St. Starbucks, closed in 2025 Blank Street, its first Rhode Island cafe
252 Thayer St. Spectrum India, closed end of May 2026 after 59 years; also the former College Hill Bookstore space Georges on Thayer, a deli
257 Thayer St. Aroma Joe's, closed end of May 2026 Dunkin, Providence's 20th
110 Waterman St. Kung Fu Tea, closed May 14 after 10 years Building demolished for mixed-use housing
Thayer Street Tiger Sugar, closed July 4 No tenant announced
Thayer Street Bagel Gourmet Ole, closed end of June No tenant announced
Thayer Street Andrea's More than a dozen letters of intent
Waterman and Brook, The Carlyle Ground floor of the apartment building Brown Bee Coffee, second location
Thayer Street New in April 2026 Maven's Jr., a Jewish deli

The table holds seven storefronts that have emptied or been torn down. Five new food or drink businesses have opened or been announced in or near the district. Three of them are coffee shops and two are delis. No new store selling goods appears in that column.

Why the old tenants left

Spectrum India had the longest run. It announced on March 14 that it would close. It first set April 30 as its last day, then got its landlord's permission to stay through the end of May. According to The Brown Daily Herald's April report, the owners gave several reasons. Parking meters made trips harder. Business fell by an estimated 40% while the Washington Bridge was closed. Snowstorms disrupted the season, the rent was high, and they felt Thayer had lost its mix of shops and restaurants. The Providence Journal confirmed that the store closed at the end of May after 59 years.

The smaller closures that followed tell a similar story. Bagel Gourmet Ole closed its Thayer shop at the end of June after the rent became more than it could afford. Its Meeting Street location is still open. At 110 Waterman St., the property manager for owner Walter Bronhard Realty told the Herald that Thayer-area commercial spaces "didn't seem to rebound since COVID." Kung Fu Tea kept struggling even after a rent reduction, and the company eventually let the owner out of the lease. The building has since been demolished, and the site is planned as mixed-use, apartment-style housing.

The Herald's October reporting on Blank Street puts it more broadly. Many Thayer businesses told the paper they had struggled with rising rents and uneven foot traffic since the pandemic. The same piece mentions earlier departures, including Berk's Shoes and Clothing.

What a landlord screens for after a year like this

Dulgarian Properties leases 218 Thayer, owns several other properties on the street, and confirmed the new tenant at 252. That gives it a large say in what the next version of Thayer looks like. In October, Dulgarian described what it wanted at 218 to the Herald. It wanted a tenant on firm financial footing that would also "go well with the community." The tenant it chose is starting from scratch. Dulgarian called it "an extensive build-out" and said new electrical, heating, plumbing and barista equipment would all go in.

Blank Street fits that description. It started in 2020 as a coffee cart in a Williamsburg garden in Brooklyn and now has more than 100 shops in the United States and the United Kingdom. Spending on a full gut and rebuild of a Thayer storefront is a bet a company that size can make.

The tenant headed for Spectrum India's old space is a different kind. Dulgarian told GoLocalProv that Georges on Thayer, a deli concept from Georges Makhlouf, is coming to 252 Thayer. Makhlouf owns Nara on Atwells Avenue and spent years as a tenant on Elmgrove Avenue with East Side Bagel. "I love his energy," Dulgarian said, adding that the owners are "working very quickly." State records show the business was incorporated in August.

A national balance sheet clears the bar, and so does a local operator the landlord already knows from another East Side lease.

A street of counters

  • Maven's Jr. opened on Thayer in April 2026. It is the second location of Maven's Delicatessen, which opened in Pawtucket in 2023. Owner Jason Sugarman told the Herald that the business makes everything from scratch, bread included. The Thayer meats are prepared and cooked on site, with stock coming from the Pawtucket kitchen.
  • Georges on Thayer is the deli announced for 252 Thayer.
  • Blank Street is the coffee and matcha cafe announced for 218 Thayer, its first in Rhode Island.
  • Dunkin is coming to 257 Thayer, and its store page lists the location as coming soon. It will be the chain's 20th location in Providence, according to the Herald.
  • Brown Bee Coffee is adding a second cafe on the ground floor of The Carlyle at Waterman and Brook streets. It will be smaller than the original and have a takeout window. A manager at the Benefit Street location, which opened in 2024, told the Herald she hopes it will be running by early 2027 at the latest.

These businesses share a format: a quick daytime purchase, priced for regular visits, with a takeout window or a counter at the center of it. Brown Bee's reasoning for the move shows it plainly. The manager said the Benefit Street cafe is "quite a trek for the Brown students," so the company went closer to campus. Thayer's new tenants are going where the walking traffic already is.

Who comes out ahead in the meantime

Fewer storefronts also means less competition for the businesses that stayed. Since the boba closures, Vivi Bubble Tea and Ten One Tea House are the only two boba shops left on Thayer. A shift supervisor at Ten One, which has been on the street for more than six years, told the Herald that the closures have been "great for business." The shop has been busier and has hired "bobaristas" who used to work at the shops that closed.

The coffee wave will play out the same way among the cafes already on the street. In the Herald's coverage of the Blank Street news, students named Ceremony and Coffee Exchange as places they already buy from. One said she plans to stay with her local favorites. Another expects to "switch it up." Dunkin's arrival got a similarly mixed reaction, and one student called it "fast, cheap and accessible" next to what else is nearby.

The spaces still in play

The former Andrea's space is the next one to watch. In October, Dulgarian told the Herald it had received "over a dozen letters of intent" for it. That is a lot of interest for one storefront. Given who has won the last few leases, the most likely winner is another tenant with money to spend on a build-out.

Two other projects will change the area more than any single cafe. At 110 Waterman St., a demolished commercial building is giving way to housing, which will add residents half a block off Thayer. Farther east, the former Eastside Marketplace at 165 Pitman St., which WPRI reported closed on Halloween 2024, has been fenced off for weeks. The Providence Journal reported on October 29 that work has started there on a new Whole Foods. Two years after the grocery closed, that space is also going to a national operator.

If you own a home within walking distance of Thayer and want to know how a changing commercial strip shows up in what nearby buyers will pay, I'm glad to go through your block and recent sales with you. You can reach me at Sabine Green and ask: What's Your Home Worth?

Expert Guidance

Helping clients navigate the real estate journey with skill, integrity, and a focus on finding the perfect home or buyer.

Follow Me on Instagram